close
close

Rotten Tomatoes confirms what the best film trilogy of all time really is

Summary

  • The Toy Story trilogy tops Rotten Tomatoes' best list, outperforming the competition in top rankings and audience appeal.
  • Rotten Tomatoes' methodology combines critical audience reviews to determine the top trio – “Toy Story” takes the lead.
  • Despite the top ranking, the debate remains as to whether “Toy Story” really has the best trilogy – other competitors do better in critical reviews.


SCREENRANT VIDEO OF THE DAY

Scroll to continue with content

Review aggregator Rotten tomatoes has released its definitive list of the best films of all time, seemingly finally settling the long-standing debate over which series constitutes the best film trilogy of all time. The ranking, which uses complex criteria that combine critical reviews, audience reaction and editorial insights, offers an extensive list of 300 of the best films of all time. Although the list was not intended to provide a definitive trilogy ranking, once compiled the results are clear.


Like any ranking of the best films of all time, the Rotten Tomatoes list – and particularly its methodology – has come under fire. According to the website, the collection is “We applied our recommendation formula, which takes into account a film's Tomatometer rating against its audience value, highlighting the beloved mood from both sides.“That makes it more than a collection of films with a 100 percent Rotten Tomatoes score and explains why you like a film.” LA Confidential rose to the top. However, this approach could also explain why a trilogy has by far the highest rated films.

Related

The 10 most surprising films on Rotten Tomatoes' list of the best films of all time

The Rotten Tomatoes list of the 300 greatest films of all time contains some surprising choices, while other excellent films are left out or ranked lower.



“Toy Story” is the best film trilogy according to Rotten Tomatoes rankings

Although Rotten Tomatoes' rankings evaluate individual films rather than films as part of a series, the full list suggests that the Toy story The series is easily the best film trilogy ever made. All three films are among the 26 best films on the list – a record that clearly surpasses all competitors. Considering that the franchise is one of the most successful of all time and has been a cross-generational hit with both audiences and critics, this position is perhaps not surprising.

Toy Story trilogy

Critic rating from Rotten Tomatoes

Audience rating

Toy story

100%

92%

Toy Story 2

100%

87%

Toy Story 3

98%

90%


Interestingly, the highest ranked Toy story The film is not the 1995 original, but the popular sequel. Toy Story 2. It is considered the eighth best film of all time and is also the highest rated animated film on the list. Toy story is just behind in 12th place, give them Toy story Series about the two best animated films of all timebefore your nearest competitor, How to train your dragon made easy (number 15). Toy Story 3 rounds out the trilogy at number 26, behind other animated films such as High, Magically goneAnd Spider-Man: Into the Spiderverse. However, regardless of the lower ranking, the series as a whole is clearly in the top spot – according to this list.

The Toy Story trilogy performs significantly better on Rotten Tomatoes than other competitors

Toy Story 4 Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes


Having three films in the top 26 films of all time is a serious achievement – regardless of context. However, Toy storyThe ranking probably becomes even more impressive if you take into account the performance of other cult series. In discussions about the best film trilogy Toy story is typically mentioned in the same breath as projects like Lord of the RingsRichard Linklaters Before series and the Indiana Jones Franchise. However, if you look at the Rotten Tomatoes list, it's clear Toy story is still a long way away of these frequent rivals.

Related

The actor with the most 100% films on Rotten Tomatoes

Several iconic actors from Hollywood's golden age have numerous 100% fresh film scores on Rotten Tomatoes, with two actors scoring the most.

While all three Lord of the rings Films are only included in the top 300 The two Towers cracks the top 50 – at number 40. Despite its sacred status among fans, it is the only one Indiana Jones Film to be included in the list Hunter of the lost treasure. Linklater is celebrated Before Films are perhaps the most enduring other trilogywith the three films ranked 50th, 166th and 172nd, but this impressive achievement pales in comparison Toy story's combined rankings.


Why Rotten Tomatoes is right about Toy Story being the best trilogy

A custom image of Buzz Lightyear and Woody from Toy Story
Custom image by Debanjana Chowdhury

Although aspects of Rotten Tomatoes' methodology and the ranking of some films may be questioned, there is no doubt that the top three Toy story Films deserve their reputation as three of the best films of all time. Each of the films tells a touching, lively and often heartbreaking story about friendship, adventure and growing up. The first Toy story pushed the boundaries of animation like never before and marked a surprising debut for Pixar Toy Story 2 surpassed the original in the emotional dimension of its story. Even after a break of 11 years Toy Story 3 brought the overall arc to a satisfying and resonant conclusion and secured the status of the series for generations.


Aside from the impressive technical and narrative achievements of the three films, as well as their ability to create timeless characters such as Woody, Buzz Lightyear, Jessie and many more, the Toy story The trilogy's consistent critical performance marks it as the best of all time. Both Toy story And Toy Story 2 are part of a select group of films that are 100% based on Rotten Tomatoes Toy Story 3 misses almost 98%. This deserved recognition, combined with everything else that makes the films great, is clearly evidence of that Toy story as one of the best series of all time, regardless of the metric used.

The title of “Best Trilogy” of Toy Story is still controversial

Elijah Wood as Frodo from The Lord of the Rings The Fellowship of the Ring Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn from The Lord of the Rings The Return of the King
Custom image by Yeider Chacon


There is no doubt that the three Toy story Films are fantastic in their own right. Each of them tells a self-contained story that functions as both an entertaining adventure and a valuable moral lesson. Although their reputation deserves recognition, There's a slight question as to whether their combined story works as effectively as other trilogies. Lord of the Rings, for example, uses three films to weave a single narrative, arguably making it a more impressive narrative achievement. Unlike other trilogies Toy story should perhaps be viewed as three separate stories rather than a complete story arc.

Considering only the site's critical average, there are other film trilogies that perform better than
Toy story
The total is 99.3%.

There's also the question of whether the trilogy should be considered the best of all time by Rotten Tomatoes' own criteria. Considering only the site's critical average, there are other film trilogies that perform better than Toy storyThe total is 99.3%. For example, every film in the so-called Noriko trilogy has a 100 percent rating on the website, as does that by Hiroshi Inagaki samurai Trilogy (although with far fewer reviews). While Toy storyThe consistently high values ​​are an important factor in the determination Rotten tomatoes The ranking makes it clear that it is not the only franchise that meets these criteria.


Source: Rotten tomatoes