Elle Fanning's true crime show with 91% RT is a great experience after “Under the Bridge” on Hulu


  • The Girl From Plainville is a critically acclaimed Hulu series that explores a shocking true crime case involving homicide and teenagers.
  • Critics praise Elle Fanning’s performance as Michelle Carter in “The Girl From Plainville,” which received 91% on Rotten Tomatoes.
  • While “Under the Bridge” focuses on a group of teenage suspects, “The Girl From Plainville” focuses on the legal consequences faced by a single person.

An acclaimed Hulu original series starring Elle Fanning is the perfect watch after the end Under the bridge. Led by star performances from Riley Keough and Lily Gladstone, Under the bridge received mostly positive reviews and achieved a critics score of 83% on Rotten Tomatoes. The 2024 true crime miniseries premiered on April 17, 2024, with the first two episodes airing before the finale of Under the bridge on May 29, 2024 with the eighth episode. The series is available exclusively on Hulu.

Under the bridge has recorded the true story of the Reena Virk case. Virk was a 14-year-old Canadian girl who was beaten and killed by a group of teenagers in Saanich, British Columbia, Canada. The miniseries features the eight teenage suspects based on the tragic and disturbing true story from 1997. The series was developed for television by Quin Shephard (Accuse, Not okay) based on the book of the same name by Rebecca Godfrey.

Hulu's “The Girl From Plainville” is another critically acclaimed true crime drama like “Under the Bridge”

It's another shocking true story about homicide, teenagers and a media frenzy

Fans of Under the bridge should be seen The Girl from Plainville from 2022. The Girl from Plainville with Elle Fanning as Michelle Carterwho was found guilty of manslaughter in the infamous 2014 “text suicide” case that resulted in the death of Conrad Roy of Plainville, Massachusetts. It is another true crime miniseries on Hulu based on a shocking true story involving manslaughter, teenagers, and a media frenzy. The series also stars Chloë Sevigny, Cara Buono, and Colton Ryan as Roy.

The Girl from Plainville was highly praised by critics upon its release on March 29, 2022, scoring 91% on Rotten Tomatoes. Matthew Gilbert of The Boston Globe wrote in his review of the series: “The Girl From Plainville doesn't have an explicit point of view that justifies itself. What it does offer, however, is an exceptional cast including Elle Fanning, Colton Ryan and Chloe Sevigny, as well as a tasteful script.” Kristen Lopez from IndieWire noted: “It's dreamy, disturbing, and actors Fanning and Ryan play it flawlessly.


The 10 best true crime TV series like “Under the Bridge”

Since the end of Under the Bridge on Hulu, viewers can watch these ten true crime series with similar themes, stories, and narrative styles.

How the reviews and true story of “The Girl From Plainville” compare to “Under the Bridge”

While Under the bridge shows an ensemble of juvenile suspects, The Girl from Plainville limits the focus to just one personas the title suggests. The legal consequences of both true-crime cases are also quite different for the defendants: Carter is serving only 15 months of a 2.5-year sentence, while Kelly Ellard, who changed her legal name to Kerry Sim, is currently serving a life sentence in Canada. The Girl from Plainville also controversy from some viewers who believe the series tried to sympathize with Carter, but fans of Under the bridge can decide for themselves.